We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer
Check your wiring before choosing anything. Systems with a dedicated power wire, called a C wire, support every thermostat. Systems without one need a model designed for it or an adapter kit. Then consider room sensors, which are what deliver real savings by heating the rooms you use rather than the one with the thermostat on the wall.
A smart thermostat does three useful things: it lets you control heating from your phone, it learns or follows a schedule so the house is not heated when empty, and with sensors it heats based on where people actually are. The savings come from the second and third, not from the app.
Check the wiring first
The single most important question is whether your system has a common wire, which provides constant power to the thermostat. Without it, a thermostat must harvest power through the heating circuit, which works for some models and causes the connection problems described in every support forum.
Turn off the power to the heating system
At the consumer unit or the system’s own switch.
Remove the thermostat's cover and photograph the wiring
Note the labelled terminals. You want to know whether a wire is connected to C.
Check for a spare wire tucked into the wall
Older installations often have an unused wire that can serve as the common, which makes everything simpler.
If there is no C wire, plan for an adapter
Several manufacturers supply one that fits at the boiler or air handler and delivers power over the existing wires.
Use the manufacturer's compatibility checker
Every major brand has one, and it asks about the terminals you just photographed.
Heating wiring can carry mains voltage, particularly in systems outside North America. If you are not confident identifying what is live, have a heating engineer fit it. The device is designed for self-installation on low-voltage systems; that assumption does not hold everywhere.
What actually saves money
- A schedule that matches when you are home, which is the largest single saving and requires nothing clever.
- Room sensors, so the system heats based on the bedroom at night and the living room in the evening rather than the hallway where the thermostat lives.
- Geofencing, which turns the heating down when the house empties, useful for irregular schedules.
- Usage reports, which show how long the heating actually ran and are more informative than people expect.
- Weather compensation, where supported, which adjusts the flow temperature to the outside conditions.
What does not save money is turning the heating on from the pub twenty minutes before you arrive, which is the feature everyone demonstrates and the one that changes nothing.
Thermostats worth considering
Google Nest Thermostat, programmable Wi-Fi thermostat
The entry point into Nest, covering the features that actually save money: scheduling, remote control and usage history. It is simpler than the Learning model and cheaper, and for most households the difference in outcome is small because a well-set schedule does most of the work.
Google Nest Learning Thermostat with temperature sensor
The learning behaviour is genuinely useful for households with irregular routines, since it builds a schedule from what you actually do rather than what you intended. The included sensor matters more: heating the room you are in rather than the hallway is the change that shows up on a bill.
ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium with sensors and voice built in
ecobee’s advantage is sensing occupancy as well as temperature, which allows the system to ignore empty rooms entirely. In a house where the thermostat is in an unrepresentative location, this fixes the fundamental problem that a single wall thermostat cannot know where anyone is.
ecobee Smart Thermostat Essential, Wi-Fi thermostat
A sensible middle option that covers scheduling, remote control and app reporting, with sensors available to add later. Buying the thermostat now and sensors when you see which rooms are wrong is a reasonable way to spread the cost.
ecobee SmartSensor two-pack for temperature and occupancy
If you already have a compatible thermostat, sensors are the upgrade to buy rather than a newer thermostat. They move the decision from the hallway wall to the rooms you occupy, which is the difference between a smart thermostat and a programmable one with an app.
What we liked
- Scheduling alone reduces heating waste noticeably
- Room sensors heat where people actually are
- Usage reports show what the system really does
- Remote control is genuinely useful when plans change
What we didn't
- Wiring compatibility decides what you can fit
- Systems without a C wire need an adapter
- Savings depend on using the schedule properly
- Heating still works when the internet does, and remote control does not
Getting the savings
Set a schedule that matches reality
Lower at night and while the house is empty. This is the largest saving and it requires no clever features.
Put a sensor in the room you use most in the evening
And another in the main bedroom. Let the system prioritise those at the relevant times.
Lower the target by one degree
Roughly the most reliable single saving available, and most people do not notice it after a week.
Check the usage reports monthly
They will show whether the schedule matches how the house is actually used.
Do not use the boost button as a routine
Repeated boosting instead of adjusting the schedule undoes the benefit.
Combine with radiator valves if you want zoning
Smart radiator valves let you heat individual rooms, which suits older houses with one heating zone.
Will a smart thermostat save me money?
Through scheduling and zoning, yes, and the savings come from heating less rather than from the device being clever. A household that already has a well-set programmable thermostat will save less than one that heats an empty house.
What is a C wire and do I need one?
A common wire providing constant power to the thermostat. Without it, the thermostat harvests power through the heating circuit, which causes connection dropouts on many models. An adapter kit solves it permanently.
Does the heating still work if the internet is down?
Yes. The thermostat keeps its schedule and controls the boiler locally. You lose remote control and app features until it reconnects.
Are room sensors worth it?
They are the feature most likely to change your bill, because they move the decision away from the hallway. In houses where the thermostat is in an unrepresentative spot, which is most of them, they matter more than the thermostat model.
Can I install it myself?
On low-voltage systems with clear terminals, usually yes. If your system carries mains voltage at the thermostat, or you are unsure what you are looking at, have an engineer do it.
How to choose
Photograph your existing wiring and run it through the compatibility checker before anything else. Plan for a C wire or an adapter if there is none. Then choose based on sensors rather than the thermostat’s own features, since heating the rooms you occupy is what produces savings. Set a schedule that matches reality and lower the target a degree, which together do more than any feature on the box.
