We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer
Decide about professional monitoring before choosing a system, because it determines the ongoing cost and, in some areas, whether police will respond. Door and window sensors deter more effectively than cameras do. And check the system works locally when the internet is down, which not all of them do.
Self-installed security systems have become genuinely capable, and they suit most homes better than a professionally installed alarm with a long contract. The decisions that matter are about monitoring, sensor coverage and what happens when the power or the internet fails, rather than about the hardware specifications.
Monitored or self-monitored?
Self-monitored means alerts go to your phone and you decide what to do. There is no monthly fee beyond any cloud storage you choose. It works well if you and someone else are usually reachable.
Professionally monitored means a staff member sees the alert, attempts to verify it and can call emergency services. It costs a monthly fee, and in some jurisdictions it is required for police response to an alarm. It also continues working when you are asleep, in a meeting or abroad.
The practical question is what happens at 3am when you are away. If nobody will act on a phone notification, monitoring is what turns the system into something that produces a response.
What to cover
- Entry sensors on every external door, including the back and side doors people forget.
- Sensors on accessible windows, particularly ground floor and anything reachable from a flat roof or a bin store.
- A motion sensor in the main circulation space, such as a hallway or a landing, which catches anyone moving through the house.
- A loud siren, which is the most effective single component. Most opportunist intruders leave when an alarm sounds.
- A visible sign or sticker, which deters before anything else happens.
- Cameras as evidence, not as deterrence. A camera records what happened; a siren stops it.
Sensors are cheap and cameras are expensive, and most people buy the wrong way round. A system with full perimeter sensor coverage and one siren is more effective at preventing a break-in than a system with four cameras and two door sensors.
Components worth considering
SimpliSafe entry sensor for windows and doors
SimpliSafe is the reference point for self-installed alarms: sensors that fit in minutes, a base station with a cellular backup option, and monitoring you can turn on and off by the month rather than signing a multi-year contract. Expanding coverage later means buying more of these.
SimpliSafe entry sensors, pack of four
Full perimeter coverage is the goal, and buying sensors in multipacks is the cheap way to get there. Cover every external door first, then accessible windows. A house where every entry point is sensed is far better protected than one with two sensors and a camera.
aosu D1 four-camera wireless security kit with solar power
If you want camera coverage as well as sensors, solar-charged cameras solve the main practical objection to battery models. Treat cameras as the evidence layer, and combine them with sensors and a siren for the part that actually prevents entry.
UltraPro personal security window and door alarm, six pack
Worth knowing about for rentals, student houses, sheds and holiday lets, where a full system is impractical. They do one thing: make a loud noise when a door or window opens. For deterrence against opportunists, that is a large share of the benefit at a fraction of the price.
2K wireless security camera system with solar panels
For people who specifically do not want a monthly fee, a system with local recording is the way to keep footage without paying for cloud storage. Check where the recordings are stored and whether that storage is itself secure, since a recorder in the hallway can be taken along with everything else.
What we liked
- Self-installation takes an afternoon and no contract
- Sensors are cheap and highly effective
- Monitoring can be added or cancelled monthly
- Alerts reach you wherever you are
What we didn't
- Self-monitoring only works if someone can respond
- Cameras record rather than prevent
- Battery devices need periodic attention
- Cloud storage fees accumulate across cameras
Questions to ask before buying
Does it work without internet?
A system that depends entirely on the cloud is defeated by cutting the broadband. Look for cellular backup and local siren operation.
Does it have battery backup?
The base station should survive a power cut. Check how long.
What happens when a sensor battery dies?
The system should alert you clearly rather than silently losing coverage.
Can you add monitoring later?
Flexibility matters, since circumstances change. Month-by-month monitoring is far better than a contract.
Does your insurer care?
Some policies require a certified alarm for a discount, and self-installed systems may not qualify. Ask before assuming a saving.
What are the local rules on alarm response?
In some areas, police attend only monitored and verified alarms. That affects whether self-monitoring achieves what you want.
Consider what the system does about false alarms before you install it. A siren that wakes the street every time a cat crosses the hallway is a system you will stop arming. Place motion sensors above pet height, use pet-immune sensors where available, and test thoroughly for a week before relying on it.
Do I need professional monitoring?
It depends on whether a phone notification will produce a response when you are asleep or away. Monitoring is what converts an alert into someone acting on it, and in some areas it is required for police attendance.
Are cameras or sensors more important?
Sensors and a siren prevent entry; cameras record it afterwards. For actual protection, cover every entry point with sensors first and add cameras later.
What happens if the intruder cuts the internet?
A well-designed system has cellular backup and sounds its siren locally regardless. A cloud-only system with no backup is defeated by unplugging the router, which is worth checking before buying.
Will a DIY system reduce my insurance premium?
Sometimes, and often not, because insurers frequently require certified installation. Ask your insurer for their specific requirement before buying on that basis.
How long do sensor batteries last?
Typically one to three years for door and window sensors, less for motion sensors and cameras. The system should warn you before one goes flat.
How to choose
Decide about monitoring first, because it sets the ongoing cost and the response you get. Buy sensors for every entry point before buying cameras, and make sure there is a loud siren. Check the system works with the internet down and the power off. Then test it for a week and fix the false alarms, because a system you stop arming protects nothing.
